Canadian Appeals Monitor Information and Commentary on Upcoming and Recent Appeal Court Decisions

Category Archives: Construction and Real Estate

Subscribe to Construction and Real Estate RSS Feed

NSCA Considers First-Ever Ministerial Order Vesting a Mining Company with Title to Private Land

Posted in Administrative, Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Municipal

The Nova Scotia Court of Appeal recently addressed what the government must do to ensure a fair process takes place before making an order transferring private land to a mining company. In Higgins v Nova Scotia (Attorney General), 2013 NSCA 106, the Court considered the first vesting order made by the Minister of Natural Resources… → Read More

SCC Declares “When in Doubt, Report” Under the Environmental Protection Act

Posted in Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Energy, Manufacturing, Transportation

In Castonguay Blasting, the Supreme Court of Canada has unanimously upheld a broad interpretation of environmental reporting obligations under Ontario’s Environmental Protection Act. The judgment, delivered by Abella J., suggests that corporations may have environmental reporting obligations even in circumstances where they would appear not to have impacted “the environment” as that term is usually… → Read More

The Constructive Trust: A Just Remedy for Unjust Enrichment?

Posted in Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate

Should the reasonable expectations of litigants determine the availability of a proprietary remedy where one party has been unjustly enriched by the other? If a proprietary remedy is available in principle, is it just to impose a constructive trust when the plaintiff never expected to earn a proprietary interest? A recent case from British Columbia,… → Read More

Buyer & Seller Beware: Zoning Irregularities in Real Estate Transactions Across the Country

Posted in Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Contracts

In decisions recently released from the Ontario Court of Appeal and the British Columbia Court of Appeal, the courts identify which party bears the burden when zoning irregularities materialize following the close of a real estate transaction. In Lee v. 1435375 Ontario Ltd., the purchaser of a dry cleaning business was prohibited from relying upon… → Read More

The Rascal Returns: The Supreme Court Reaffirms Doctrine of Constructive Trust in Nishi v. Rascal Trucking Ltd.

Posted in Case Comments, Class Actions, Construction and Real Estate, Contracts, Corporate Law, Manufacturing, Municipal

The Supreme Court has issued its decision in the case of Nishi v. Rascal Trucking Ltd., 2013 SCC 33, clarifying the scope of the resulting trust doctrine, in the commercial context. The Court reaffirmed its own precedent and refused to abolish well-established doctrine in the absence of a “compelling” reason for doing so, strong dissents… → Read More

What’s the Value of a Truck Stop Without Any Trucks? Supreme Court Addresses Nuisance Claims in Public Projects

Posted in Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Torts, Transportation

In a new decision, the Supreme Court of Canada has provided guidance on when compensation might be due in cases of nuisance caused by public infrastructure projects.  The Antrim decision is relevant not only for those involved in the management of public projects, but it also shapes the more general law of nuisance, especially in… → Read More

Toward an Even Playing Field: The Supreme Court of Canada to Rule on Disclosure of Amounts in Pierringer Settlements Prior to Trial

Posted in Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Procedure

The Supreme Court has granted leave to appeal in a case that may elucidate the scope of discovery under Nova Scotia’s “semblance of relevance” test, in addition to the scope of settlement privilege and the entitlement of non-settling parties to know the settlement amounts under a Pierringer agreement in advance of the trial.

Hot Off the Press – World Class Actions: A Guide to Group and Representative Actions Around the Globe

Posted in Aboriginal, Class Actions, Communications, Construction and Real Estate, Energy, Financial Services, Franchise and Distribution, Health, Insurance, Media, Municipal, Procedure, Professions, Securities, Transportation

In the newly published World Class Actions: A Guide to Group and Representative Actions Around the Globe, McCarthy Tétrault litigators David Hamer and Shane D’Souza co-authored the “Multijurisdictional and Transnational Class Litigation: Lawsuits Heard ‘Round the World” chapter. The chapter offers guidance to international lawyers who represent clients involved in cross-border, multinational and international class… → Read More

Can the Queen Be Taken at Her Word? Federal Court of Appeal Answers in Canada v. South Yukon Forest Corporation

Posted in Administrative, Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Contracts, Energy, Torts

The Federal Court of Appeal has clarified when the federal Crown will be held responsible for representations made by its officers. In issuing its decision, the Court opted for a narrow interpretation of the Crown’s liability and reiterated that parties that rely on the Crown’s representations have the responsibility to conduct their own due diligence.

The Backside of a Truckstop: SCC to Rule on Balancing Competing Interests in Nuisance Cases

Posted in Case Previews, Construction and Real Estate, Torts, Transportation

The Supreme Court of Canada has granted leave to appeal in Antrim Truck Centre Ltd. v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of Ontario, a case that is expected to provide clarity about the law of nuisance, particularly in cases where the social utility of the defendant’s activity is arguably very high…. → Read More

OCA to Consider Jurisdiction of Superior Court Over Construction-Related Claim Against Municipality

Posted in Case Previews, Class Actions, Construction and Real Estate, Torts

Summary The OCA will soon decide whether the Ontario Superior Court, as opposed to the Ontario Municipal Board, has jurisdiction over a claim by a class of failed businesses against a municipality for damages flowing from a local construction project. Decision The case involved a construction project by the City of Toronto and the Toronto… → Read More

Will Your Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act Superpriority Still Be that Super once the Scheme of Collocation is Drawn Up?

Posted in Bankruptcy and Debt, Case Comments, Construction and Real Estate, Financial Services

In the context of an arrangement plan pursuant to the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act, a financial institution was granted a superpriority on all moveable and immoveable debtors’ assets following an additional $2,150,000 loan to the debtor, in order to allow it to complete some construction projects it had already started and for which it already owed… → Read More