Are lower courts obliged to follow precedents of the Supreme Court of Canada, even if those precedents are decades-old and have been the subject of extensive criticism? And when should the Court overrule one of its own precedents? The Court recently addressed both of these questions in Canada v. Craig, a tax case involving the… → Read More
The Supreme Court has granted leave to appeal in a case that may elucidate the scope of discovery under Nova Scotia’s “semblance of relevance” test, in addition to the scope of settlement privilege and the entitlement of non-settling parties to know the settlement amounts under a Pierringer agreement in advance of the trial.
The constitutionalization of private international law has been one of the major projects of the Supreme Court of Canada since the decision in Morguard. However, the precise relationship between the Constitution, and the “real and substantial connection” test, has yet to be fully defined. In the Van Breda Trilogy, the Supreme Court returned to this… → Read More
The Supreme Court of Canada agreed earlier this summer to hear the appeal in Patricia McLean v. Executive Director of the British Columbia Securities Commission, an interesting case that raises several legal issues relevant to provincial securities commissions and the extra-provincial reach of securities litigation. With the Court’s decision last week to dismiss the leave application in… → Read More
This winter, the SCC will have the opportunity to clarify how the courts should go about determining how strictly to interpret restrictive covenants where they relate to both an employment agreement and the sale of a business. The opportunity arises from the Supreme Court’s decision to grant leave in Guay Inc. c. Yannick Payette et… → Read More